We attempted to try 3 pizza places in one evening here in the Raleigh area. First up was NY Pizza which has 3 places in Cary. (Read the reviews on Google!) We stopped at the one close to I-40 and it was excellent. It scored a 100 on the Sliker Scale and 4.5 stars on the Yummy scale.
Next stop was down on the campus of NC State, where on Hillsborough Street there are at probably a dozen or more piza places such as Amore’s, Marco’s, & Sylvia’s. We stopped at I Love NY Pizza. As we walked in we immediately saw the giant-sized 24″ slice pies. Nonetheless, the look of the pies and the spanish-speaking help behind the counter made me think this wasn’t what we were looking for. No Sicilian, no Italians to be found… The place scored 80 on the Sliker Scale but just 3.5 stars for the Yummy factor.
Lastly we stopped at Lilly’s Pizza near the five points area. It wasn’t really New York Style. It seemed like a cool place to hang out with some friends and get pizza and a beer. We ate outside and I enjoyed a slice, but again, not New York Style Pizza. Lilly’s scored a 65 on the Sliker Scale and 3.5 stars for the Yummy factor.